More Startups For the Rest of Us episodes

Episode 857 | Finding Hidden Multipliers in Your Business (with Jason Cohen) thumbnail

Episode 857 | Finding Hidden Multipliers in Your Business (with Jason Cohen)

Published 3 Nov 2026

Duration: 00:50:45

Growth strategies include leveraging profit whales, adjusting pricing to signal quality, shifting messaging from savings to value, charging for implementation, and aligning strategy with founder strengths.

Episode Description

What if raising your prices could actually bring in more customers? In this episode, Rob Walling welcomes back Jason Cohen, founder of WP Engine and S...

Overview

Jason Cohen discusses his book Hidden Multipliers, which presents growth levers that are "pretty much mechanistic, meaning like it almost always is true just because of the structure of a company." The book covers 11 chapters, each addressing a multiplier that can break through stalled growth without requiring new budgets or teams. Cohen frames the core problem as founders hearing the same patterns repeatedly - "the company was growing for a while and now it's not" - yet lacking a structured way to identify which lever actually matters.

Key topics include the "profit whale" concept, where a small percentage of customers generate most profit while another small percentage destroys it. At WP Engine, fewer than 10% of 7,000 customers caused a million dollars a year in profit loss, dragging gross margin from 80% to 55%. Cohen also explores pricing strategy (SmartBear moved from $35 to $1,300 per seat over time, with unit sales increasing), messaging reframing (shifting from "cut your ad spend in half" to "double your leads at the same cost per lead" grew a product from 5k to 40k monthly), and matching strategy to a founder's own attributes rather than forcing a purely market-driven plan.

The book is accompanied by free AI skills that facilitate working through these frameworks via structured, challenging questions rather than providing direct answers.

What If

  • What if you computed your profit per customer and discovered your tail is costing you more than you think?

    • Move: Pull 12 months of revenue and delivery costs per customer, sort most-to-least profitable, plot the cumulative curve. Flag the bottom 10 - 20% and top 10%.
    • Why Now? At WP Engine, "fewer than 10% of our customers were causing a million dollars a year in profit to be gone," dragging gross margin from 80% to 55%. If your margin is below expectations, the tail may be the biggest lever.
    • Expected Upside (proposed): You may find a handful of customers driving disproportionate support load. Fixing the root cause (e.g., a self-serve option) could shift accounts from unprofitable to profitable, as at WP Engine where it "literally went from unprofitable to profitable".
  • What if you rewrote your homepage and sales-call script to sell created value instead of saved cost, then price-tested on your next three calls?

    • Move: Reframe your pitch (e.g., "cut your ad spend in half") as the outcome the customer already budgets for (e.g., "double your leads at the same cost per lead"). Lead with that framing on your next three calls.
    • Why Now? A savings pitch caps your price at a fraction of the saved amount; a value-creation pitch lets you charge "that whole extra 40k" because the customer "already said with their behavior that's what they're willing to spend for that". One product went from 5k to 40k monthly on this reframe.
    • Expected Upside (proposed): You may discover prospects respond more strongly to outcome framing, giving you a basis to raise price or improve close rate without changing the product.
  • What if you inventoried your own attributes before choosing your next strategic bet, rather than defaulting to what the market seems to want?

    • Move: List five salient personal attributes. For each, note where it's a strength and where a weakness in a software business. Draft two one-paragraph strategies: one leaning into your top two strengths, one requiring you to be strong where you're weak.
    • Why Now? Cohen argues "you only need like one or two really really great strength special strengths which the strategy also needs to succeed to win", and that a strategy requiring you to be amazing at something you're terrible at "would be the wrong strategy for you".
    • Expected Upside (proposed): You may eliminate a strategy you'd pursue out of market pressure, freeing focus on a narrower play where your natural attributes compound rather than fighting against them.

Takeaway

  • Compute gross margin per customer (revenue minus servers, support, tokens) and sort all customers from most to least profitable. Identify the bottom segment - Cohen found "fewer than 10% of our customers were causing a million dollars a year in profit to be gone" at WP Engine - and investigate each one before considering termination; the fix may be a missing self-serve feature.
  • If your product has been at the same price for over a year, test a price increase on your next three sales calls. Cohen notes "the price determines the market that you're in" - mid-market buyers may not have considered you at a lower price.
  • Rewrite your primary pitch from a savings frame ("cut your ad spend in half") to a value-creation frame ("double your leads at the same cost per lead"). This removes the implicit price cap a savings narrative imposes and lets you charge for the full value the customer already budgets for.
  • Charge an implementation fee even if you ultimately waive it. Put the amount on the invoice (e.g., "implementation 20k discount 20k") to create reciprocity. A customer who invests 20k is more likely to stay long-term.
  • Before choosing your next strategic direction, list your top two salient personal attributes and confirm the strategy makes them strengths. Cohen advises "you only need like one or two really really great strength special strengths which the strategy also needs to succeed to win," so avoid plans requiring you to excel where you're weak.

Recent Episodes of Startups For the Rest of Us

10 Nov 2026 Episode 858 | How to Build Products People Want

Rob Walling explains how his new book, Idea to Traction, helps early-stage founders validate ideas and navigate the AI era, emphasizing that human learning remains essential despite faster building tools.

6 Oct 2026 Episode 853 | How to Become the SaaS That AI Recommends

"Ross Hudgens of Siege Media explains the shift to Generative Engine Optimization (GEO), an AI-driven expansion of SEO that incorporates offsite factors like affiliate mentions, emphasizing its role as an extension - not replacement - of traditional SEO, while highlighting strategies for B2B SaaS and the future of AI in search."

More Startups For the Rest of Us episodes