More The EntreLeadership Podcast episodes

Why You Shouldnt Promote Your Best Employee thumbnail

Why You Shouldnt Promote Your Best Employee

Published 13 Nov 2026

Duration: 00:10:43

Effective leadership promotion requires verifying competency, opportunity, and motivation, not just performance metrics.

Episode Description

Your best employee could become your worst leader. In this episode, you'll learn the three things to look for before promoting someone into leadership...

Overview

The episode addresses the risk of promoting the wrong person into leadership, illustrating the point with a top sales performer whose "numbers were phenomenal" but who was "rude and entitled and downright sneaky," manipulated customers about prices, and was ultimately let go rather than promoted. The speaker argues that being the best performer in a role does not automatically make someone ready to lead people, and that promoting the wrong person "can create an even bigger problem than the one that you're trying to solve."

The speaker outlines three characteristics to evaluate before promoting someone: competency for the specific new role, a genuine opportunity with budget and ROI justification, and the right motivation. Competency means evaluating skills for "the job you're about to give them, not just the one that they have now." Opportunity requires confirming there is an actual leadership role, the budget to fill it, and a clear return on investment. Motivation must center on helping others win rather than seeking titles and salary.

The speaker recommends starting conversations about leadership aspirations in one-on-ones, defining what a great leader would be doing a year into the role, and developing competency while waiting for the right opportunity. Technical skills can be taught, but leadership qualities that are absent are much harder to build.

What If

  • What if you, as a solo developer, are about to hire your first tech lead and are tempted to pick your most productive contributor?

    • Move: Before making the call, write down the specific problems the tech lead would own (code reviews, architecture decisions, mentoring juniors) and the conversations they would need to have weekly, then score each candidate against that list rather than against their commit history or ticket throughput.
    • Why Now?: The source warns that "Competency in one area doesn't automatically mean they're competent in another," so evaluating a strong individual contributor solely on output risks the "double whammy" of losing a key builder and gaining a leader the team does not respect.
    • Expected Upside: You may identify a different engineer who already "coaches people without being asked" as the stronger fit, though this is a possibility, not a guarantee.
  • What if you are spending most of your week in code reviews, on-call rotations, and architecture meetings, and you are considering whether a new lead is actually justified?

    • Move: Track your hours for two weeks; if you are spending roughly "15 hours a week" on tasks a tech lead could own, define concretely what you would do with that freed time (customer discovery calls, sales outreach, product roadmap work) before posting the role.
    • Why Now?: The source cautions that promoting without a clear ROI produces "an expensive leader without a clear purpose" who ends up "to just walk around and micromanage people," so the budget and the use of freed hours must both be real.
    • Expected Upside: You could potentially redirect that time toward revenue-generating activities, though this is a proposed outcome, not a source fact.
  • What if your most senior developer is technically brilliant but you are unsure whether they actually want to lead or just want a bigger title and salary?

    • Move: In your next one-on-one, ask directly, "Do you want to lead a team someday?" and "Why do you want to lead?" then note whether their answer centers on helping others or on "all the trappings of leadership."
    • Why Now?: The source warns that if motivation is misaligned, "you're setting them up to be miserable," which can lead to disengagement or turnover.
    • Expected Upside: You can begin "developing their competency while you wait for the right opportunity to open up," building a leadership pipeline before you desperately need one, though this is a proposed path, not a certainty.

Takeaway

  • Before promoting anyone, write down the specific problems the new leader will solve and the hard conversations they will have daily, then evaluate candidates against that list rather than their current performance metrics.
  • Count your direct reports; if you exceed five, you likely have a management-span problem, but only move forward if you can articulate what the freed-up hours will be used for and the budget supports the role.
  • In your next one-on-one, ask each senior team member whether they want to lead and specifically why, then note whether their answer centers on helping others or on title and compensation.
  • Identify who on your team already coaches others without being asked and whom people naturally go to for help, as these are signals of leadership competency that raw technical output will not reveal.
  • Define what a great leader in the target role would be doing one year from now - what they would own, how the team would be performing - then begin developing that person's relevant skills before the role is vacant.

Recent Episodes of The EntreLeadership Podcast

16 Nov 2026 I Cant Promote My Best Employee

Leaders should retain top performers without promotion opportunities by honestly addressing business constraints and reinforcing the team's connection to the organization's core mission and values.

11 Nov 2026 3 Products That Made Absolutely No Sense

ESPN, Ford, and Harley-Davidson failed by ignoring customer needs and market shifts, illustrating the need to kill unprofitable or distracting products.

6 Nov 2026 How I Built a 7-Figure Business From My Garage

John Youngblood built JJ George from a side hustle into a million-dollar business by solving grill accessory problems, eventually manufacturing the Smarter Scrubber domestically in the US.

More The EntreLeadership Podcast episodes