More Copywriters Podcast episodes

Prize Fight:Human Copywritervs. AI thumbnail

Prize Fight:Human Copywritervs. AI

Published 2 Nov 2026

Duration: 00:32:11

A virtual prize fight between an AI and a human copywriter evaluates who performs better in various copywriting tasks, with the human winning six to four.

Episode Description

In late September, here in San Francisco, a man named Frankie LaPenna held three cage fights against robots in a cage match. Human vs. robot. And he w...

Overview

A structured ten-round competition pits a human copywriter against an AI on specific copywriting tasks, from finding a "big idea" to drafting a first pass using proven structures like AIDA or PAS. The human wins six rounds - big idea, market awareness judgment, headline quality, client interviews, emotional understanding, and organizing raw material - while the AI takes four: mining customer reviews, breaking down competitor promotions, picking winners from options, and quickly producing a usable first draft.

The discussion centers on where each excels: AI handles speed, quantity, and data processing, while humans retain advantages in creativity, rapport, emotional depth, and strategic judgment. A recurring theme is collaboration over competition - using AI as a "superpower" for research and drafting while applying human taste and experience to the final output. The hosts note that the most effective framing is "me with AI" rather than "me versus AI."

A persistent caveat is that AI capabilities are shifting rapidly; the hosts acknowledge that "who knows what's going to change by then" within weeks of publication. The human copywriter also identifies storytelling as a frontier where "AI just makes up crazy stuff and doesn't really get what makes a good persuasion story," a gap he has not seen AI close.

What If

  • What if you used AI to mine your users' support tickets and community forum posts for exact language, then applied your own judgment to select the phrases most likely to resonate in your product copy?
    • Move: Export your last 50 support tickets and relevant forum threads into a structured document, then prompt AI to extract recurring pain-point phrases and the exact words users employ. You then choose which phrases to deploy.
    • Why Now?: The source notes a "drastic improvement" in AI mining within "the last couple of months", making this step significantly faster than manual reading while still requiring human selection.
    • Expected Upside (proposed): A messaging refresh grounded in your users' own vocabulary could improve landing-page conversion, since the source identifies exact prospect language as a high-value copywriting input.
  • What if you reframed your next A/B test decision by asking AI "what's their most likely next step" for each avatar rather than "which version will they buy"?
    • Move: Write 3 - 5 short avatar descriptions for your product, then prompt AI: "Out of these five people, if they read version A versus version B, what's their most likely next step?" Compare the output against your own gut before shipping.
    • Why Now?: The source reports this specific framing "gets it right more often than not", suggesting a concrete prompt pattern that outperforms the default "pick a winner" approach.
    • Expected Upside (proposed): Fewer test cycles and faster iteration, since you would be using a question structure the source credits with higher accuracy in predicting user behavior.
  • What if you used AI to decompose your three closest competitors' landing pages into a structured table of promises, mechanisms, proof, and guarantees, then layered in your own market-awareness judgment?
    • Move: Paste each competitor's copy into AI with a prompt requesting extraction of promises, proof/substantiation, mechanism, and guarantees. Review the output against your knowledge of your specific audience before drawing conclusions.
    • Why Now?: The source calls this a "superpower" when working with AI rather than against it, and notes AI excels at thoroughness and speed for analytical breakdowns.
    • Expected Upside (proposed): A differentiated positioning statement that targets gaps in the competitive landscape, avoiding the "driving straight towards a cliff" error of trusting AI output without human market context.

Takeaway

  • Mine your customer reviews and forum posts with AI for speed, but treat selection as a separate human step: AI is "good at" mining, but "choosing them" remains your job.
  • When asking AI to evaluate two options, reframe from "which will they buy" to "what's their most likely next step after reading A versus B" for measurably better predictions.
  • Use AI to break down competitor promotions into promises, mechanisms, and guarantees, then apply your own market-awareness judgment to avoid the "driving straight towards a cliff" failure mode.
  • Deliberately develop your emotional understanding of the prospect's experience, since the source identifies it as what "closes the sales" and "gets your fees up," and notes it requires sustained practice.
  • Use AI for a fast first draft or brainstorm, then add your own "teeth" to avoid output that sounds "safe, sanitized, sounding mid" - the source warns that business owners who skip this step "get the worst results".

Recent Episodes of Copywriters Podcast

16 Nov 2026 The Money Is In The Unasked Questions

Addressing unspoken prospect fears, distinct from objections, is critical for converting high-ticket sales by removing uncertainty and building trust.

26 Oct 2026 What To Do When An Offer Stalls Out

"Assess and adapt offers by testing variables, staying agile, and leveraging authenticity to overcome market misalignment, overpromising, or outdated positioning."

19 Oct 2026 Scientists Reveal Extreme Sales Shortcut

"Readability in copywriting significantly impacts sales and conversions, with font choice, sentence structure, and word selection influencing perception and trust, while 14 techniques and psychological strategies optimize effectiveness."

12 Oct 2026 7 More Eternal Truths Of Copywriting

"Timeless copywriting principles focus on psychology, strong CTAs, and overcoming irrational fears, with real-world examples proving effective techniques remain unchanged, while modern tools and testing enhance persuasive advertising."

More Copywriters Podcast episodes