More Copywriters Podcast episodes

Prize Fight: Human Copywritervs. AI  REMATCH! thumbnail

Prize Fight: Human Copywritervs. AI REMATCH!

Published 9 Nov 2026

Duration: 00:31:00

A human copywriter and AI compete in ten copywriting tasks, with humans excelling in creativity and AI in data tasks.

Episode Description

Last week, we held a prize fight between a human copywriter and an AI, or, at least a virtual prize fight.Here's the background:In late September, her...

Overview

The podcast presents a structured comparison between a human copywriter and an AI across ten copywriting tasks, framed as a virtual "prize fight." Each round assigns a specific task - ranging from writing in a distinctive voice to analyzing campaign data - and the participants decide which side performs better. The format is explicitly non-physical: "No robots or people will be harmed by the events about to take place on our show today."

The human copywriter wins six and a half rounds to three and a half, with one tie. The human takes rounds on voice, objection handling, offer shaping, line editing, storytelling, and diagnosing failed promotions. The AI wins rounds on reformatting winning copy for different platforms, gathering proof, and flagging claims needing legal review. The tie goes to analyzing test results, where the participants conclude that "this is when the human and the robot work together that's when we actually get the victory."

Key themes include AI's tendency to add "a bunch of fluff that would never pass a copy chief's desk" and sound "too cool to be believable," its cheerleader-like reluctance to push back on clients, and its inability to replicate the "gut check" that guides human judgment in storytelling and market resonance. The participants note that AI excels at analysis and gathering but struggles with creation, particularly narrative and authentic voice.

What If

  • What if you built a "product voice file" from your own user interviews and support transcripts, then fed it to AI before finalizing any marketing copy?

    • Move: Record your user interviews and support calls, compile them into a reference document, and prompt AI to "pick up their mannerisms" before a final pass, as the source describes loading a "client voice file".
    • Why Now? The source notes AI "is very needy for acceptance and approval and so it's trying so hard to be cool" and adds "a bunch of fluff that would never pass a copy chief's desk".
    • Expected Upside: As a possibility, this could reduce your rewrite cycle, since the source states that without such refinements "I do not think that it comes out with a believable voice at all".
  • What if you used AI to gather competitor objections and user complaints, then applied your own judgment to prioritize which ones to address in your next release?

    • Move: Prompt AI to "role play a skeptical prospect and list objections" across your niche, then you sort and filter because "it can gather it, can it sort it and filter? I think that requires a human hand, a human in the loop".
    • Why Now? The source observes AI "tends to complicate objections or questions by adding too many additional points" while "humans know what's really going to be on another human's mind more than AI does".
    • Expected Upside: As a possibility, you get a broader objection list faster while retaining human prioritization, since "the big decider for me is who's better at prioritizing these objections".
  • What if you wrote your product's landing-page copy at full overboard, then instructed AI to flag every claim needing substantiation before you publish?

    • Move: Draft your copy going "one hundred and ten percent go overboard if necessary", then prompt AI to "find areas where maybe I'm making an unsubstantiated claim" and "find areas where I might run into legal issues".
    • Why Now? The source notes AI "a lot of times will just go balls to the wall" but "if you tell it go through my copy find areas where maybe I'm making an unsubstantiated claim... It does a really good job of that but only if you tell it to".
    • Expected Upside: As a possibility, you reach a legally safer draft faster, since the source concludes "when instructed the AI does a better job of this".

Takeaway

  • Record client or user interviews and build a "voice file" to feed AI before final copy passes. "I record all of my client interviews and I create a client voice file and I say, hey, read through this recording, pick up their mannerisms".
  • Use AI to evaluate and refine your own drafts rather than generating copy from scratch. "having the AI evaluate something you've tried to do in the prospect's voice after it's already analyzed the actual prospect's voice is a much smarter way to use it than trying to have it create".
  • Build a format-specific prompt system (email, subject line, headline, video script) over months. Garfinkel notes he "built it out over nine, 10 months now and it works great but out of the box I don't think that it works as well".
  • After drafting, explicitly instruct AI to flag unsubstantiated claims, legal risks, and believability gaps. "if you tell it go through my copy find areas where maybe I'm making an unsubstantiated claim find areas where I might run into legal issues. Find areas where I might even run into just believability issues. It does a really good job of that but only if you tell it to".
  • For storytelling, write your own interview answers and have AI restate them without the questions, then edit. "if you're going to use AI to write a story just write interview questions and then have it repeat your answers without the questions and edit that".

Recent Episodes of Copywriters Podcast

16 Nov 2026 The Money Is In The Unasked Questions

Addressing unspoken prospect fears, distinct from objections, is critical for converting high-ticket sales by removing uncertainty and building trust.

2 Nov 2026 Prize Fight:Human Copywritervs. AI

A virtual prize fight between an AI and a human copywriter evaluates who performs better in various copywriting tasks, with the human winning six to four.

26 Oct 2026 What To Do When An Offer Stalls Out

"Assess and adapt offers by testing variables, staying agile, and leveraging authenticity to overcome market misalignment, overpromising, or outdated positioning."

19 Oct 2026 Scientists Reveal Extreme Sales Shortcut

"Readability in copywriting significantly impacts sales and conversions, with font choice, sentence structure, and word selection influencing perception and trust, while 14 techniques and psychological strategies optimize effectiveness."

12 Oct 2026 7 More Eternal Truths Of Copywriting

"Timeless copywriting principles focus on psychology, strong CTAs, and overcoming irrational fears, with real-world examples proving effective techniques remain unchanged, while modern tools and testing enhance persuasive advertising."

More Copywriters Podcast episodes